Being 35, I was bathed in Star Wars (both the movies and the Hasbro toys) for most of my life.
I saw Empire Strikes back when I was 5, I saw A New Hope when I was 10 and I waited for 2 hours, alone in front of a movie theater to see Return of the Jedi when I was 12… and loved every fraking second of the 3rd movie.
While I concede 100% that George Lucas is not the best caretaker of the Star Wars Franchise, I’m going to make enemies of the geek community by saying that we should all take a freaking chill pill and get that proverbial fan stick out of our butts about Star Wars.
In my mind, apart from Empire Strikes back, the Star Wars saga are not particularly good movies in terms of original Story or acting. They were original because they created the Sci-Fi genre as a viable cinematographic form in a time where disaster and road rally movies ruled.
The reason why I like the original movies so much is because I was so damn young when I saw them, and in those years, movies about spaceship, glowing swords, stuff that exploded and dark evil guys that turn to be a daddy with a (somewhat) good heart were just plain awesome! They left a deep emotional impression that I still live with.
That’s why I didn’t dislike the prequels. Yes they featured the same (or worse) cheesiness found in the original movies. Being an adult when I saw them, I had to strain my suspension of disbelief past the breaking point to resist the countless fridge logic moments and paper thin character depth.
But it was still about spaceships, glowing swords, stuff that explodes and a Dark Good guy that makes a Face heel turn. I particularly liked Revenge of the Sith because it allowed us to see the Clone Wars and how Anakin and Obi-wan were such bad asses.
Don’t mistake me, there were atrocious moments in those movies, like Jar Jar, the love scene of Attack of the Clone (George, if you aren’t going to develop your characters, at least don’t put a love scene, it’s like PG-rated porn), Anakin’s ‘Okay Chancellor, where do I sign up to be a Sith?’ conversion and the laughable ‘higher Ground’ shtick.
As a movie geek, I much preferred Iron Man and The Dark Knight, no contest.
However, as a 26-33 year old kid, I also liked the new Star Wars movies. I remember that when I was watching Phantom Menace for the 1st time, I kept saying ‘I can’t believe I’m watching a new Star Wars movie!!!’
And in that vein, I found the animated Star Wars movie, the Clone Wars, that I saw with my 6 year old, to be a good Star Wars movie. Heck, it had better character play than most other movies of the franchise! I liked how each clone officer developed a name and a different look. I liked that it showed how Anakin did not transition from a jerk teenager to a Sith wannabe directly and was actually a noble hero and all around nice guy for quite some time.
Heck the whole Hutt family thing was cute, if a bit flimsy as a plot device… but who cares! There were spaceships, glowing swords, stuff that exploded and and Dark Evil chicks that actually talked while fighting!
Weeee!
Yes the canon characters and core plot had no room to evolve since the movie is an in-betwener. Given these huge constraints, SW the Clone war was an enjoyable dose of my favorite Sci-Fi opera.
In fact, I think that should the 6 movies be remade in the future, I’d go as far as say that CGI animation is the way to go.
Peace out.